08/15/2026
SATURDAY NIGHT AT THE MOVIES – Was there ever a more energetic and purely likable actress than Debbie Reynolds? From the first moment Gene Kelly sees her chorus dancing in “Singin’ in the Rain” to their marvelous dancing in the “Good Morning” number, Debbie just leaps off the screen. Leaping may be the operative word here, because she started out in high school as a gymnast.
Although she was all over the gossip columns in the early 1960s as her marriage to crooner Eddie Fisher imploded when he left her to dally with Elizabeth Taylor, she also made some fun movies – one of which I sampled for the first time this week – “The Second Time Around.”
The title sounds like a contemporary romantic comedy, but this story takes place in 1911. Debby is Lucretia “Lu” Rogers, a widow with two children, living precariously in New York City. Based on a job tip, she leaves her kids with her grandmother and train travels out to pre-statehood Arizona, only to discover that the guy who offered her the job has been murdered. Broke and desperate, she offers her services as a novice ranch hand for Aggie Gates (the marvelous Thelma Ritter). Aggie is doubtful, especially when she watches Lu attempt to load a heavy sack of grain into a wagon, but she eventually offers her a one month trial.
Meanwhile, Lu has attracted the attention of two local men – roguish gambling house owner Dan Jones (a terrific Steve Forrest), and mama’s boy rancher Pat Collins (Andy Griffith in full hick mode). Not to suffer fools gladly, Lu also nails corrupt Sheriff Burns (Ken Scott, perfectly villainous) as a bully and racist – and as you’ll see when you sample this perfectly entertaining vehicle, she becomes the town sheriff.
Kudos to writers Richard Emery Roberts, Oscar Saul and Clair Huffaker for a really fun narrative, and veteran director Vincent Sherman for keeping this comedy feast moving. We see various sides of Debbie, and they are all winning ones as she becomes an empowered woman in a male-dominant Wild West. Incidentally, Debbie and Thelma would reteam the following year for the terrific “How the West Was Won.”